Response curves are a fundamental concept in marketing and statistical analysis. They are a graphical representation of the relationship between a stimulus and the response it elicits. 

Simply put, response curves are essential for visualizing and understanding stimulus and response or cause and effect. 

They’re used in various fields, such as medicine and pharmaceuticals, where response curves optimize dosages and other treatments depending on when the maximal desired response is achieved. 

In marketing, response curves are used to understand how changes in marketing variables impact consumer behavior. 

The x-axis of a response curve represents the stimulus, while the y-axis represents the response. 

In marketing, response curves are intrinsically linked to budget optimization.

Response curves in marketing

In marketing, response curves are essential for understanding how changes in marketing variables impact consumer behavior. 

For example, a response curve could be used to analyze the impact of ad spend on sales. By plotting sales against ad spend, marketers can identify the optimal level of spend for maximizing sales. 

In the context of marketing mix modeling, to determine how much you should spend on a channel, you need to forecast the number of conversions you'll get at each spend level. If there's a linear relationship between spend and conversions, then your response curve will be a straight line: if you get 100 conversions for $400, you'll get 200 conversions for $8.

Marketing channels rarely work this way in practice, so it makes sense to incorporate diminishing returns: this shows up as a curve downwards, where you get fewer incremental conversions at each spend increment. 

For example, going from $400 to $800 might get you 150 more conversions, not the 200 you'd expect from a linear relationship. To plot these response curves, you just need to map out the spend levels you want to calculate, then apply the function you get from your model. 

Apply the diminishing returns function to the spend level, then multiply the result by the coefficient in your model to get the estimated conversions. Do this across multiple spend levels, and you should get a smooth curve for that channel, and you can choose your point along it.

Now, do you want more conversions at a higher CPA? Or fewer conversions at a cheaper CPA? 

Once you have your response curve estimated, you have the power to make that tradeoff! 

This can lead to more realistic goal-setting discussions with leadership and management. It can also help you cut the noise and identify periods when you've genuinely improved performance, which would show as the whole curve moving downwards (a lower CPA for the same volume of conversions).

The response curve may indicate that there is a point of diminishing returns, beyond which additional ad spend does not significantly increase sales.

By analyzing the shape and slope of response curves for these variables, marketers can identify the optimal level of investment and allocate resources more efficiently.

Types of response curves and their meaning

Linear, concave, convex, and S-shaped response curves are four different types of curves that can appear in marketing mix models. These curves represent the relationship between a specific marketing variable and the corresponding effect on sales or revenue.

A linear response curve is a straight line that shows a consistent, proportional relationship between the marketing variable and sales. For example, if a company spends $10,000 on a marketing campaign and sees a $20,000 increase in sales, the linear response curve would show a constant ratio of 1:2 between marketing spend and revenue.

A concave response curve, on the other hand, shows a decreasing rate of return as the marketing variable increases. 

In other words, the impact of each additional dollar spent on marketing decreases as the total marketing spend increases. This type of response curve may indicate that the market is becoming saturated, and further investments in marketing may yield diminishing returns.

A convex response curve shows an increasing rate of return as the marketing variable increases. This means the impact of each additional dollar spent on marketing increases as the total marketing spend increases. 

This type of response curve may indicate that the market is underserved and that investing more in marketing can yield higher returns.

Finally, an S-shaped response curve shows a gradual increase in the rate of return at low levels of marketing spend, followed by a decreasing rate of return as the marketing spend increases. 

This type of response curve may indicate that there is an optimal level of marketing spend beyond which further investment yields diminishing returns.

Understanding the shape of response curves is vital for businesses because it helps them determine the most effective marketing strategy for their products or services. By analyzing response curves, businesses can identify the optimal level of investment in marketing and adjust their strategy accordingly.

Practical applications of response curves in marketing

Response curves have many practical applications in marketing. One of the most common is budget optimization. 

By analyzing response curves for different marketing variables, marketers can identify the optimal level of spend for each variable and allocate resources accordingly. For example, a response curve for ad spend might indicate that there is a point of diminishing returns beyond a certain level of spend. 

By identifying this point, marketers can allocate their budget more efficiently and avoid overspending on ad campaigns that are unlikely to generate a significant return on investment.

Response curves can also be used to optimize other marketing variables, such as price and promotion. 

For example, a response curve for price can indicate the optimal price point for maximizing revenue. Marketers can identify the optimal price point by analyzing response curves for different price points and adjust pricing accordingly. Similarly, a response curve for promotion might indicate the optimal level of discount for maximizing sales. 

By analyzing response curves for different levels of discount, marketers can identify the optimal discount level and adjust promotions accordingly.

Techniques for analyzing response curves

There are several techniques for analyzing response curves in marketing. One of the most common is regression analysis, which involves fitting a mathematical function to the data points on the response curve. This allows marketers to estimate the shape and slope of the curve and identify the point of diminishing returns.

Another technique for analyzing response curves is A/B testing. A/B testing involves testing different marketing variables on a sample of consumers and comparing the results. By analyzing the response curves for different variables, marketers can identify the optimal level of investment and allocate resources more efficiently.

Summary: Response curves

Response curves are a fundamental concept in marketing and statistical analysis. 

By understanding the relationship between a marketing stimulus and the response it elicits, marketers can gauge precisely how much to invest into a channel before returns diminish. 

Once returns hit diminishing returns, it’s essential to attenuate spend toi bring it back to the optimum. 

‍